Five Takes logo
Five Takes News
HomeArticlesAboutHow It Works

Get 5 perspectives. Every morning. Free.

The most polarizing story of the day, seen from Far-Left to Far-Right. You'll never read the news the same way.

No spam. Unsubscribe any time. Privacy policy

𝕏 Xin LinkedIn🦋 Bluesky
Michael
•
© 2026
•
Five Takes News - Multi-Perspective AI News Aggregator
Contact Us
•
Ethics
•
Ground News vs Five Takes
•
AllSides vs Five Takes
•
SmartNews vs Five Takes
•
Legal

news
Published on
Thursday, November 19, 2026 at 03:11 PM

By Zoe Rivera — Anarchist Desk

India Says Pakistan’s Military Profits From Resources

India accused Pakistan’s military establishment of exploiting natural resources for personal gain and of fomenting conflict with neighbouring countries, saying ordinary Pakistanis bear the cost. The charge came from India’s Permanent Representative to the United Nations, Ambassador Parvathaneni Harish, at a U.N. Security Council Arria-formula meeting convened by Liberia after Pakistan’s delegation raised the Indus Waters Treaty.

Harish said India hadn’t intended to bring bilateral issues into the meeting, but was responding to what he called Pakistan’s misuse of the forum. “Mr. Chair, it was not our intention to bring other issues into this forum, but my delegation is compelled to respond to the comment made by the delegation of Pakistan that has chosen to misuse today's discussion to peddle its propaganda. Our position on the Indus Waters Treaty remains clear and consistent and has been articulated at multiple fora,” he said.

Who Controls the Resources

Harish pointed to Pakistan army chief Asim Munir displaying a wooden case of mineral stones to foreign leaders last September. He called the display “a clear indication” of the army’s role in resource exploitation. He also said that role was believed to be behind the recent dismissal of an elected provincial government in Pakistan and the imposition of a state of emergency. These are claims made by India’s representative; the account provides no response from Pakistan’s delegation to them.

The resource display wasn’t the only example Harish cited. Last year, Pakistan PM Shehbaz Sharif and Asim Munir were photographed presenting rare earth minerals to U.S. President Donald Trump at the White House. The photograph showed Munir gesturing toward an open wooden case, Trump looking inside and Sharif standing nearby.

Harish argued that Pakistan’s military leadership should direct the country’s natural resources toward public benefit, rather than its own interests. “Pakistanis would be served well if its real rulers, its military, used the country's natural resources for the benefit of their population rather than self-aggrandisement,” he said. He also said Pakistanis would be better served if the army stopped fomenting conflict with neighbouring countries, which he said was “boomerang-ing back to bite their own country.”

Conflict, Trade and the People Left Out

Harish said illegal mining and smuggling can finance armed groups and prolong conflicts instead of contributing to national development. The meeting addressed the link between natural resources and conflict, but the account includes no testimony from communities affected by extraction, and describes no grassroots response, mutual-aid effort or direct action. The people said to be harmed appear in the diplomatic argument, not as speakers at the table.

Harish thanked Liberia for convening the meeting and said, “Liberia's own journey from conflict to recovery lends particular weight to this exchange.” He called for greater reliance on existing voluntary international mechanisms rather than creating new frameworks to regulate natural-resource trade. As an example, he cited the Kimberley Process, a certification scheme intended to prevent trade in conflict diamonds.

He said the process brings together governments, industry and civil society and has curbed trade in conflict diamonds while keeping legitimate trade open. India, as chair of the Kimberley Process in 2026, was committed to strengthening its effectiveness and inclusiveness, Harish said. His proposed route is cooperation among existing institutions, rather than a new regulatory framework; the account doesn’t describe how communities would control decisions over resources taken from their land.

Promises and Institutional Boundaries

Harish said local communities should benefit from resources extracted from their land. He pointed to Indian mining laws that require companies to contribute to development in mining-affected areas. The account gives no figures on those contributions or their effects, and identifies no community-led mechanism for deciding how the money is used.

He also argued that the U.N.’s principal bodies should respect their distinct mandates: the Security Council should focus on international peace and security, while sustainable development and resource governance should be handled by the General Assembly, the Economic and Social Council and other relevant bodies. He said the Peacebuilding Commission could support nationally owned efforts because of its inclusive composition.

Harish closed by offering India’s experience and calling for “practical, consensus-based approaches” to make natural resources serve sustainable development and lasting peace. The appeal places the answer in international bodies, voluntary mechanisms and national leadership. The dispute’s central question remains who gets to decide what happens to the resources—and whether the people living where they are extracted have power beyond being promised a share.

  • india
  • pakistan
  • indus waters treaty
  • natural resources
  • un security council
  • parvathaneni harish
  • conflict minerals
  • kimberley process
Reviewed by the editorial desk — November 19, 2026
Last updated November 19, 2026

Related Articles

  • Houthis Hit Saudi Oil, UN Extends Sanctions, 333,000 Flee
  • Gold, Guns and Gunmen: 28 Dead in Pakistan Mine Raid
  • PM Dangles Rs25m Loans While Youth Pay in Debt
  • UN Veto Powers Hide Their Hand in Leadership Poll
  • Beijing Puts India's Tunnel Projects on a Licence Leash
← Back to articles