European leaders gathered in Berlin on November 19 to discuss continued support for Ukraine as Donald Trump, Xi Jinping and Vladimir Putin were due to meet in Shenzhen. One room would count the costs of funding a war; the other would put three presidents at the centre of a conversation about world affairs. Ukraine wasn’t expected to be on the trilateral agenda.
Who Gets a Seat
The meeting was scheduled for about 8:10 a.m. CET on the sidelines of the Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation summit. Euronews described it as historic. Its expected agenda included denuclearisation and the Iran war, but not Ukraine, according to Euronews’ Europe Today programme.
At least 40 Coalition of the Willing members were set to meet in Berlin, according to Euronews. POLITICO described the alliance as having more than 35 nations, while Al Jazeera said more than 30 leaders were expected. The gathering was centred on continued support for Ukraine, with Trump’s envoys Jared Kushner and Steve Witkoff expected to meet senior officials from Ukraine, European allies, NATO and the EU.
The summit invited comparisons with the 1945 Yalta Conference, where Winston Churchill, Franklin Roosevelt and Joseph Stalin helped shape the postwar order, including the division of Europe into competing spheres of influence. Latvia, Lithuania and Estonia were particularly affected by that settlement: their Soviet occupation and annexation went unchallenged by the Western Allies.
Norwegian Foreign Minister Espen Barth Eide said he didn’t believe the trilateral would create new international spheres of power. “The last thing anyone desires is an 'agreement between great leaders to divide the world between them,'” he said. “I'm not suggesting that's going to happen, but I mean this is something we don't want to see.”
Fredrik Wesslau, senior policy fellow at the European Council on Foreign Relations, said Putin would probably try to discuss Ukraine and conclude the full-scale invasion. “He wants Russia, the US and China to decide everyone else's geopolitical fate,” Wesslau said. “But in the end it's impossible to decide on the fundamentals of European security without Europeans.” Zelenskyy said in November: “We don't want to have Yalta 2.0. We don't want to be divided by Russia.”
Red Lines, Real Money
Representatives from the E5—Germany, France, Italy, Poland and the United Kingdom—were to meet alongside the Coalition of the Willing to discuss Europe’s red lines in possible ceasefire negotiations. The five countries, together with Council and Commission officials, had been tasked with speaking with Russia after an informal European Council summit in Dublin on Friday.
Toomas Hendrik Ilves, former President of Estonia, criticised US policy under Trump, citing criticism of Ukrainian attacks on Russian oil refineries and data centres. “(Undersecretary of War) Elbridge Colby came out and started criticising the Ukrainians for their rocket attacks on Russian oil refineries and on data centres, which was kind of bizarre, given what the Russians are doing to Ukraine on a daily basis,” Ilves said.
Ilves praised German Defence Minister Boris Pistorius for pushing back against Washington’s criticism of Ukraine’s deep-strike campaign at a NATO headquarters meeting on Tuesday. “For the first time, you saw that Defence Minister Pistorius said, 'That's really stupid.' I mean, for once, we saw some backbone on the part of an EU minister standing up to this really Russophilic approach that the US has taken for a while,” Ilves said.
The European Commission proposed an additional €45 billion loan for Ukraine in 2027: up to €25 billion for military aid and €20 billion for budget support. A €1.71 billion payment under an existing EU loan was made on Monday for drones, ammunition and air defence. Even with the proposed loan, Ukraine would face a projected €25 billion financing gap next year. The proposal’s interest costs and repayment terms were also part of the discussions around the Berlin meeting.
The Infrastructure Question
Energy Commissioner Dan Jørgensen said an agreement to accelerate permitting procedures would help revamp the bloc’s obsolete power grid and boost electrification, while financing remained an obstacle. “This is about making sure that we have the infrastructure to actually electrify our societies, to get the renewable energy into our systems so that we can drive our cars on electricity, we can have heat pumps and so forth,” he said. “Instead of being 27 member states, we are trying to be one energy union.”
The agenda in Berlin spans military support, budget loans, ceasefire terms and energy infrastructure. The figures leave the immediate question in view: even after a proposed €45 billion loan, the projected gap remains €25 billion.
- donald trump
- xi jinping
- vladimir putin
- ukraine
- coalition of the willing
- berlin
- european union
- ukraine funding